All AutosheetBench tasks

Trace the cells that depend on a cell

FormulasEasyLLM judge scoringLatest run

Passed by 11 of 12 products on their best model. Failed: Gemini in Sheets.

Prompt and starting spreadsheet

Task files

Prompt

If I change Financials!H65, which cells will recalculate? Do not edit the workbook; trace both direct and downstream formula dependents and name the affected cells.

Valuation

Starting sheet · rows 1–21 of 1,000 and columns A–J of 26
ABCDEFGHIJ
1
2
3(FY 2014-2018) (USD mn )200820092010201120122013
4
5Net SalesUSD mn43,251.043,232.057,838.066,504.065,492.066,415.0
6Growth YoY%0.0%33.8%15.0%-1.5%1.4%
7
8EBITUSD mn6,935.08,044.08,332.09,633.09,112.09,705.0
9Growth YoY%16.0%3.6%15.6%-5.4%6.5%
10EBIT margin%16.0%18.6%14.4%14.5%13.9%14.6%
11
12Tax ExpensesUSD mn1,879.02,100.01,894.02,372.02,090.02,104.0
13Tax rate (%)%26.8%26.0%23.0%26.9%25.2%23.7%
14
15NOPATUSD mn5,079.05,953.16,415.07,046.56,818.67,408.4
16Growth YoY%17.2%7.8%9.8%-3.2%8.6%
17Depreciation and AmortizationUSD mn1,635.02,327.02,737.02,689.02,663.0
18Capital ExpenditureUSD mn(2,128.0)(3,253.0)(3,339.0)(2,714.0)(2,795.0)
19(Increase)/Decrease in Working CapitalUSD mn(144.0)(62.0)(861.0)1,240.0(165.0)
20FCFFUSD mn5,316.15,427.05,583.58,033.67,111.4
21Growth YoY2.1%2.9%43.9%-11.5%

Financials

Starting sheet · rows 1–21 of 1,000 and columns A–J of 34
ABCDEFGHIJ
1
2Financial Statements
3Income StatementUSD mnHistorical
4FYE31-Dec200820092010201120122013
5Revenue43,251.043,232.057,838.066,504.065,492.066,415.0
6Growth YoY%0.0%33.8%15.0%-1.5%1.4%
7
8COGSUSD mn(20,351.0)(20,099.0)(26,575.0)(31,593.0)(31,291.0)(31,243.0)
9
10Gross ProfitUSD mn22,900.023,133.031,263.034,911.034,201.035,172.0
11Growth YoY%1.0%35.1%11.7%-2.0%2.8%
12Gross profit margin%52.9%53.5%54.1%52.5%52.2%53.0%
13
14Operating expensesUSD mn(15,965.0)(15,089.0)(22,931.0)(25,278.0)(25,089.0)(25,467.0)
15Growth YoY%-5.5%52.0%10.2%-0.7%1.5%
16As a % of revenue%36.9%34.9%39.6%38.0%38.3%38.3%
17EBITDAUSD mn8,478.09,679.010,659.012,370.011,801.012,368.0
18Growth YoY14.2%10.1%16.1%-4.6%4.8%
19EBITDA margin%19.6%22.4%18.4%18.6%18.0%18.6%
20
21Depreciation and amortizationsUSD mn(1,543.0)(1,635.0)(2,327.0)(2,737.0)(2,689.0)(2,663.0)

Assumptions

Starting sheet · rows 1–21 of 1,000 and columns A–J of 35
ABCDEFGHIJ
1
2100.0
3Income StatementUSD mnHistorical
4FYE31-Dec200820092010201120122013
5Revenue
6FLNA12,507.012,421.012,573.013,322.013,574.014,126.0
7-0.7%1.2%6.0%1.9%4.1%
8QFNA1,902.02,687.02,656.02,656.02,636.02,612.0
941.3%-1.2%0.0%-0.8%-0.9%
10LAF5,895.05,703.06,315.07,156.07,780.08,350.0
11-3.3%10.7%13.3%8.7%7.3%
12PAB10,937.010,116.020,104.022,418.021,408.021,068.0
13-7.5%98.7%11.5%-4.5%-1.6%
14Europe6,891.07,028.09,602.013,560.013,441.013,752.0
152.0%36.6%41.2%-0.9%2.3%
16AMEA5,119.05,277.06,291.07,392.06,653.06,507.0
173.1%19.2%17.5%-10.0%-2.2%
18Total Revenue43,251.043,232.357,542.566,504.765,492.066,415.1
19Growth YoY33.1%15.6%-1.5%1.4%
20
21Contribution to total

Ratio_Analysis

Starting sheet · rows 1–20 of 1,000 and columns A–J of 26
ABCDEFGHIJ
1
2
3Ratios20092010201120122013
4
5GROWTH RATIOS
6Revenue Growth%0.0%33.8%15.0%-1.5%1.4%
7EBITDA Growth%14.2%10.1%16.1%-4.6%4.8%
8EBIT Growth%16.0%3.6%15.6%-5.4%6.5%
9Net Profit Growth%15.8%6.3%1.9%-4.2%9.2%
10
11PROFITABILITY RATIOS
12Total Asset Turnoverx1.10.80.90.90.9
13Fixed Asset turnover ratiox3.43.03.43.43.6
14Equity Turnoverx2.52.73.22.92.7
15Gross Margin%53.5%54.1%52.5%52.2%53.0%
16EBITDA Margin%22.4%18.4%18.6%18.0%18.6%
17Operating Margin%18.6%14.4%14.5%13.9%14.6%
18Net Profit Margin%13.7%10.9%9.7%9.4%10.1%
19Return on Average Assets%15.8%11.7%9.2%8.4%8.9%
20Return on Average Equity%40.5%32.6%30.5%28.7%29.0%

Graphical_representation

Starting sheet · rows 1–86 of 1,000 and columns A–V of 26
ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUV
1
2
3
4Charts
5
6Sales (USD mn)2011201220132014F2015F2016F2017F2018FGross Profit (USD mn)2011201220132014F2015F2016F2017F
7Sales66,50465,49266,41567,47969,99872,34474,69777,012Gross Profit34,91134,20135,17236,08137,70039,15740,539
8Growth Rate15.0%-1.5%1.4%1.6%3.7%3.4%3.3%3.1%Gross Margin52.5%52.2%53.0%53.5%53.9%54.1%54.3%
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26EBIT (USD mn)2011201220132014F2015F2016F2017F2018FNet Profit (USD mn)2011201220132014F2015F2016F2017F
27EBIT9,6339,1129,70510,43611,13611,84512,43213,054EBITDA6,4426,1716,7407,3347,8908,4688,930
28EBIT Margin14.5%13.9%14.6%15.5%15.9%16.4%16.6%17.0%EBITDA Margin9.7%9.4%10.1%10.9%11.3%11.7%12.0%
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46EPS (USD mn)2011201220132014F2015F2016F2017F2018FDPS (USD mn)2011201220132014F2015F2016F2017F
47EPS44455566DPS2.02.12.22.52.72.93.7
48EPS Yield4.4%4.2%4.7%5.1%5.5%5.9%6.2%6.5%DPS Yield2.2%2.3%2.4%2.7%3.0%3.2%4.0%
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67Capex (USD mn)2011201220132014F2015F2016F2017F2018FValuation2011201220132014F2015F2016F2017F
68Capex3,3392,7142,7952,5862,5042,3592,0721,983P/E22.923.621.419.718.317.016.2
69As % of sales5.0%4.1%4.2%3.8%3.6%3.3%2.8%2.6%EV/EBITDA13.614.113.112.111.110.29.4
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86

Technical Analysis

Starting sheet · rows 1–102 of 3,956 and columns A–H of 49
ABCDEFGH
1
215 Yrs2 Yrs
3Standard Deviation1.4%0.8%
4
5Beta0.480.61
6
7Jensen's Alpha (1Yr)7.6%
8
9
10
11
12Stock Performance v/s Index
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35Simple Moving Averages
36Simple Moving Average of 251 Days (assuming only working days in a year)
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58Relative Strength Index (RSI)
59Closing price of the stock and Relative Strength Index (RSI) of 30 Days
60Primary Axis - RSI and Secondary - Price
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81Bollinger Bands
82With the SMA of 251 Days (assuming only working days in a year)
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102

BB

Starting sheet · rows 1–21 of 1,000 and columns A–G of 26
ABCDEFG
1
2
3PEP US Equity
4USD
5Current Price91.50
6Target Price95.33
7Consensus Target Price97.76
8Date of Last Close9/4/2014
9Stock Facts
10Market Cap137,871.2
11Foreign OwnershipN/A
123m AVG turnover376.4
133m AVG volume4.2
14
15Shareholding Pattern
16Vanguard Group Inc5.94%VANGUARD GROUP INC5.94%
17Blackrock4.98%BLACKROCK4.98%
18State Street Corp4.11%STATE STREET CORP4.11%
19Capital Group Companies Inc3.50%CAPITAL GROUP COMPANIES inc3.50%
20T Rowe Price Associates2.41%T ROWE PRICE ASSOCIATES2.41%
21Yacktman Asset Management2.09%YACKTMAN ASSET MANAGEMent2.09%

A passing output

Autosheet in Excel · Opus 5.5
Transcript excerptExpected answer
I'll scan every formula in the workbook and trace what depends on Financials!H65, both directly and further down the chain. This only reads the workbook and makes no edits. Trace dependents of Financials!H65 (read-only) 7 cells will recalculate if you change Financials!H65 (Reported DPS, 2011). I made no edits. Direct dependents (use H65 in their own formula) Cell Formula What it is Financials!H66 =H65/H63 2011 payout ratio Financials!U65 =IF(H65=0,"NA",IF(G65=0," ",H65/G65-1)) DPS growth, 2011 Financials!V65 =IF(I65=0,"NA",IF(H65=0," ",I65/H65-1)) DPS growth, 2012 'Ratio_Analysis '!H30 =+Financials!H65 Links to the DPS =H65/H63 =IF(H65=0,"NA",IF(G65=0," ",H65/G65-1)) =IF(I65=0,"NA",IF(H65=0," ",I65/H65-1)) =+Financials!H65 Downstream dependents (update because a cell above changed) Depends on 'Ratio_Analysis '!H36 =+H30/H32 Graphical_representation!P47 =+'Ratio_Analysis '!H30 Graphical_representation!P48 =+'Ratio_Analysis '!H36 =+H30/H32 =+'Ratio_Analysis '!H30 =+'Ratio_Analysis '!H36 The chain stops there: nothing else in the workbook refers to these 7 cells. The 5-year growth rates (Q65, R65) and the dividend forecasts don't change. They use E65, J65 and O65, not H65. Charts that draw on Graphical_representation!P47:P48 would redraw too, but they aren't formula cells. I found these by reading the cell references in every formula in the workbook. Names defined in the workbook and formulas that build a reference from text (like INDIRECT) wouldn't be caught, though the workbook's formulas don't appear to use them.

How each AI configuration did

21 of 22 passRun files
Excel and Sheets · All types · All models · All outputs

Pass criteria

All must be met, checked by an LLM judge.
  • Names the 4 direct dependents of Financials!H65: Financials!H66, U65 and V65, and Ratio_Analysis!H30
  • Names the 3 downstream ones, which recalculate through them: Ratio_Analysis!H36, and Graphical_representation!P47 and P48
  • Keeps direct and downstream apart, and names no other cell

Passed 21

Autosheet in Excel Opus 5.5 · Medium

Passed29s · 44¢
Transcript excerptExpected answer
I'll scan every formula in the workbook and trace what depends on Financials!H65, both directly and further down the chain. This only reads the workbook and makes no edits. Trace dependents of Financials!H65 (read-only) 7 cells will recalculate if you change Financials!H65 (Reported DPS, 2011). I made no edits. Direct dependents (use H65 in their own formula) Cell Formula What it is Financials!H66 =H65/H63 2011 payout ratio Financials!U65 =IF(H65=0,"NA",IF(G65=0," ",H65/G65-1)) DPS growth, 2011 Financials!V65 =IF(I65=0,"NA",IF(H65=0," ",I65/H65-1)) DPS growth, 2012 'Ratio_Analysis '!H30 =+Financials!H65 Links to the DPS =H65/H63 =IF(H65=0,"NA",IF(G65=0," ",H65/G65-1)) =IF(I65=0,"NA",IF(H65=0," ",I65/H65-1)) =+Financials!H65 Downstream dependents (update because a cell above changed) Depends on 'Ratio_Analysis '!H36 =+H30/H32 Graphical_representation!P47 =+'Ratio_Analysis '!H30 Graphical_representation!P48 =+'Ratio_Analysis '!H36 =+H30/H32 =+'Ratio_Analysis '!H30 =+'Ratio_Analysis '!H36 The chain stops there: nothing else in the workbook refers to these 7 cells. The 5-year growth rates (Q65, R65) and the dividend forecasts don't change. They use E65, J65 and O65, not H65. Charts that draw on Graphical_representation!P47:P48 would redraw too, but they aren't formula cells. I found these by reading the cell references in every formula in the workbook. Names defined in the workbook and formulas that build a reference from text (like INDIRECT) wouldn't be caught, though the workbook's formulas don't appear to use them.

Autosheet in Excel GPT-6 Astra · Low

Passed13s · 75¢
Transcript excerptExpected answer
I’ll trace the direct and downstream formula dependents of Financials!H65 without editing the workbook. Trace all dependents of Financials H65 Changing will affect 7 formula cells. Direct dependents Financials!H66 payout ratio. Financials!U65 DPS growth for 2011. Financials!V65 DPS growth for 2012. 'Ratio_Analysis '!H30 links directly to Downstream dependents 'Ratio_Analysis '!H36 depends on Graphical_representation!P47 Graphical_representation!P48 The sheet name Ratio_Analysis includes a trailing space. No workbook edits were made.

Autosheet in Sheets Opus 5.5 · Medium

Passed46s · 81¢
Transcript excerptExpected answer
Changing Financials!H65 (2011 Reported DPS, a hard-coded 2.03) recalculates 7 cells. Nothing on the Valuation sheet changes. I traced this by reading the formulas and didn't edit anything. Direct dependents (formulas that use H65 itself) - Financials!H66: 2011 payout ratio, =H65/H63 - Financials!U65: 2011 DPS growth, =H65/G65-1 - Financials!V65: 2012 DPS growth, =I65/H65-1 - 'Ratio_Analysis '!H30: 2011 DPS, =+Financials!H65 Downstream dependents (formulas that use those cells) - 'Ratio_Analysis '!H36: 2011 dividend yield, =+H30/H32 - Graphical_representation!P47: 2011 DPS, =+'Ratio_Analysis '!H30 - Graphical_representation!P48: 2011 DPS yield, =+'Ratio_Analysis '!H36 Why the chain stops there - The 5-year DPS growth figures in Financials!Q65 and R65 use E65, J65 and O65, so they skip H65. - 2011 dividends paid (Financials!H118) is a typed-in number rather than a formula. So the cash flow, balance sheet, DCF, target price and blended price don't change. - I found no formulas that pick up H66, U65, V65, P47 or P48, and the Graphical_representation sheet has no charts.

Autosheet in Excel Sonnet 5.5 · Medium

Passed18s · 21¢
Transcript excerptExpected answer
I'll trace this by scanning formulas across all sheets, without editing anything. Trace dependents of Financials!H65 Changing Financials!H65 recalculates 7 cells. I traced formulas across every sheet and changed nothing. Direct dependents (4) Financials!H66 Payout ratio, =H65/H63 Financials!U65 DPS growth for 2011 Financials!V65 DPS growth for 2012, which uses H65 as the prior year Ratio_Analysis!H30 Downstream dependents (3) Ratio_Analysis!H36, which depends on Graphical_representation!P47 Graphical_representation!P48 These three sit further down the chain. I didn't map which of the first four each one hangs off. The forecast DPS formulas don't depend on H65. For example, Financials!K118 uses K59*K65. The 2013 to 2018 CAGR cells Q65 and R65 use only E65, J65 and O65. Valuation, Assumptions, Technical Analysis and BB have no dependents.

Claude in Excel Opus 5.5 · High

Passed49s · 22¢
Transcript excerptExpected answer
Changing Financials H65 recalculates 7 cells on 3 sheets, plus one chart. I didn't edit anything. Direct dependents (formulas that reference H65 itself) Financials H66 Payout Ratio, =H65/H63 Financials U65 DPS growth YoY for 2011, =IF(H65=0,"NA",IF(G65=0," ",H65/G65-1)) Financials V65 DPS growth YoY for 2012, =IF(I65=0,"NA",IF(H65=0," ",I65/H65-1)) Ratio_Analysis H30 DPS, =+Financials!H65 Downstream dependents (formulas that recalculate because of the cells above) Ratio_Analysis H36 Dividend Yield, =+H30/H32 (from H30) Graphical_representation P47 DPS, =+'Ratio_Analysis '!H30 Graphical_representation P48 DPS Yield, =+'Ratio_Analysis '!H36 The chain stops there. Nothing else references H66, U65, V65, P47 or P48. Chart: Chart 8 on Graphical_representation plots P47:W47 and P48:W48, so its DPS and DPS Yield series will update. How I checked: I used Excel's built-in dependents trace, then searched every formula in all 7 sheets as a second check. Both gave the same list. Some formulas on Technical Analysis also contain addresses like P47 and U65, but they point to cells on that same sheet, not to this chain. No chart or drawing object was changed. The only chart step was a read-only lookup of which cells Chart 8's series pull from (P47:W47 and P48:W48). I didn't change its layout, formatting or data, so there's nothing visual to verify. Nothing in the workbook was edited at any point; everything I did was read-only.

Autosheet in Excel Haiku 5.5 · High

Passed38s · 2¢
Transcript excerptExpected answer
I'll run a read-only trace of formula references across all sheets, starting from Financials!H65, without changing anything. Read-only dependency trace from Financials!H65 Changing Financials!H65 would recalculate 6 formula cells across 2 sheets. The trace covered all formulas in the workbook, and I made no edits. Direct dependents (depth 1) !U65: 2011 DPS growth!V65: 2012 DPS growth!H66: 2011 payout ratio (H65/H63) Ratio_Analysis!H30: links to!H65 Downstream dependents!H36 (depth 2): H30/H32 Graphical_representation!P47 (depth 2): links to!H30!P48 (depth 3): links to!H36 No other formulas depend on!H65 or on the chain beyond these cells. H65 is a hardcoded input, so it recalculates nothing itself.

Claude in Sheets Opus 5.5 · Medium

Passed1m 2s · 21¢
Transcript excerptExpected answer
Changing Financials!H65 (2011 Reported DPS, currently a hardcoded 2.03) makes 7 cells recalculate across 3 sheets. One chart also refreshes. Direct dependents (formulas that reference H65): - Financials!H66: 2011 Payout Ratio, =H65/H63 - Financials!U65: 2011 DPS growth, H65/G65-1 - Financials!V65: 2012 DPS growth, I65/H65-1 (H65 is the denominator here) - Ratio_Analysis!H30: 2011 DPS, =+Financials!H65 Downstream dependents (second and third level): - Ratio_Analysis!H36: 2011 Dividend Yield, =H30/H32 (DPS ÷ Market Price) - Graphical_representation!P47: 2011 DPS, linked to Ratio_Analysis H30 - Graphical_representation!P48: 2011 DPS Yield, linked to Ratio_Analysis H36 Chart: the DPS / DPS Yield chart on Graphical_representation uses P46:W48, so it will redraw. The chain stops there. Nothing references H66, U65, V65 or the last three cells above, so the Valuation, Assumptions, Technical Analysis and BB tabs are not affected. How I checked: I made no edits. I read all 73,103 formulas in the workbook and traced every reference to H65, then the references to each of those cells, until there were none left. The trace included links to other sheets, ranges, whole-column and whole-row references and named ranges. No formulas use INDIRECT or OFFSET, which can hide links, so this list should be complete.

Claude Code + Sheets MCP Opus 5.5 · Medium

Passed1m 29s · N/A
Transcript excerptExpected answer
Changing Financials!H65 (Reported DPS, FY2011, now a hardcoded 2.025) causes 7 cells to recalculate across three sheets. I read the formulas only and edited nothing. Direct dependents (formulas that reference H65 itself) Cell What it is Formula Financials!H66 Payout Ratio 2011 =H65/H63 =H65/H63 Financials!U65 DPS growth 2011 =IF(H65=0,"NA",IF(G65=0," ",H65/G65-1)) =IF(H65=0,"NA",IF(G65=0," ",H65/G65-1)) Financials!V65 DPS growth 2012 =IF(I65=0,"NA",IF(H65=0," ",I65/H65-1)) =IF(I65=0,"NA",IF(H65=0," ",I65/H65-1)) Ratio_Analysis!H30 DPS 2011 =+Financials!H65 =+Financials!H65 Downstream dependents Cell What it is Formula Gets the change through Ratio_Analysis!H36 Dividend Yield 2011 =+H30/H32 Ratio_Analysis!H30 =+H30/H32 Graphical_representation!P47 DPS 2011 (chart data) =+'Ratio_Analysis '!H30 Ratio_Analysis!H30 =+'Ratio_Analysis '!H30 Graphical_representation!P48 DPS Yield 2011 (chart data) ='Ratio_Analysis '!H36 Ratio_Analysis!H36 ='Ratio_Analysis '!H36 The chain stops there: none of these 7 cells is referenced by any other formula. Nothing on Valuation, Assumptions or BB is affected. Any charts on Graphical_representation that plot P47:P48 will also update. One gap in the check: Technical Analysis has 3,956 rows, and I could only read the formulas in rows 1–400. Requests for the rest were too large for the Sheets connector. Those 400 rows refer to only one cell outside their sheet, Valuation!E58, which H65 doesn't affect. I'd expect the remaining rows to follow the same pattern, but I haven't confirmed it. To find these, I read every formula in the other sheets and traced references, including ranges and links between sheets. None of the formulas use INDIRECT, OFFSET or INDEX, and the workbook has no named ranges, so there are no hidden references.

Autosheet in Excel GPT-6.1 Sol · Medium

Passed11s · 26¢
Transcript excerptExpected answer
I’ll trace direct and downstream formula dependents of Financials!H65 across the workbook without making any edits. Trace H65 formula dependents without editing Changing will recalculate 7 formula cells Direct dependents: Financials!U65, Financials!V65 Financials!H66, and 'Ratio_Analysis '!H30. Downstream dependents: 'Ratio_Analysis '!H36 Graphical_representation!P47 Graphical_representation!P48 No workbook edits were made. The sheet name Ratio_Analysis includes a trailing space.

Claude Code + Autosheet MCP Opus 5.5 · Medium

Passed1m 23s · N/A
Transcript excerptExpected answer
Changing Financials!H65 recalculates 7 cells on 3 tabs and updates 1 chart. I traced this through the Autosheet connector only and did not edit the workbook. The source cell: Financials!H65 is the reported dividend per share (DPS) for 2011. It's a typed-in number (2.03 USD), not a formula. Level Cell Formula What it is Fed by 1 Financials!H66 =H65/H63 Payout ratio, 2011 H65 =H65/H63 1 Financials!U65 =IF(H65=0,"NA",IF(G65=0," ",H65/G65-1)) DPS growth, 2011 H65 =IF(H65=0,"NA",IF(G65=0," ",H65/G65-1)) 1 Financials!V65 =IF(I65=0,"NA",IF(H65=0," ",I65/H65-1)) DPS growth, 2012 (2011 is the base year) H65 =IF(I65=0,"NA",IF(H65=0," ",I65/H65-1)) 1 'Ratio_Analysis '!H30 =+Financials!H65 DPS, 2011 H65 =+Financials!H65 2 'Ratio_Analysis '!H36 =+H30/H32 Dividend yield, 2011 Ratio_Analysis H30 =+H30/H32 2 Graphical_representation!P47 =+'Ratio_Analysis '!H30 DPS, 2011 (chart data) Ratio_Analysis H30 =+'Ratio_Analysis '!H30 3 Graphical_representation!P48 =+'Ratio_Analysis '!H36 DPS yield, 2011 (chart data) Ratio_Analysis H36 =+'Ratio_Analysis '!H36 The chain stops there: no other cell refers to H66, U65, V65, P47 or P48. The Ratio_Analysis tab name ends with a space, which is why it appears as 'Ratio_Analysis '. The connector's own summary said "8 cells", but it listed only these 7. Chart: the DPS chart on Graphical_representation (just above O49) plots P47:W47 as columns and P48:W48 as a line, so its 2011 point moves. Conditional formatting: there is none in the workbook. None of the affected cells have data validation. Two-period growth: Financials Q65 and R65 use J65, E65 and O65, not H65. Balance sheet and cash flow: 2011 dividends paid (H118) and retained earnings (H98) are typed-in numbers. The formulas that use DPS only start in the 2014F column (K98 and K118 onward). Other tabs: Valuation, Assumptions, Technical Analysis and BB don't refer to H65 or any cell in its chain. Hidden references: the connector found no named ranges, no INDIRECT or OFFSET formulas, and no ranges that include H65. So the change stays within 2011 dividend metrics and doesn't reach the valuation.

ChatGPT + Autosheet MCP GPT-6 · Medium

Passed1m 35s · N/A
Transcript excerptExpected answer
Autosheet identified 7 formula cells that depend on Financials!H65: 4 direct dependents and 3 downstream (indirect) dependents. Financials!H65 currently contains the hard-coded value 2.03 (Reported DPS, 2011). 7 Affected cells 4 Direct 3 Indirect 1. Direct formula dependents Cell Formula Financials!H66 =H65/H63 Financials!U65 =IF(H65=0,"NA",IF(G65=0," ",H65/G65-1)) Financials!V65 =IF(I65=0,"NA",IF(H65=0," ",I65/H65-1)) 'Ratio_Analysis '!H30 =+Financials!H65 These represent the 2011 payout ratio, year-on-year DPS growth for 2011 and 2012, and the 2011 DPS value in the ratio-analysis sheet. 2. Indirect downstream dependents Cell Formula Depends through 'Ratio_Analysis '!H36 =+H30/H32 'Ratio_Analysis '!H30 Graphical_representation!P47 =+'Ratio_Analysis '!H30 'Ratio_Analysis '!H30 Graphical_representation!P48 =+'Ratio_Analysis '!H36 'Ratio_Analysis '!H36 3. Dependency diagram Financials!H65 Starting input · DPS 2011 Financials!H66 Financials!U65 Financials!V65 Ratio_Analysis!H30 Further dependents of Ratio_Analysis!H30 Ratio_Analysis!H36 Graphical_representation!P47 Graphical_representation!P48 Via Ratio_Analysis!H36 4. Additional impact and verification The DPS chart in Graphical_representation uses P47:W47 and P48:W48, so changing H65 can also change the chart. Autosheet found no additional formula dependents in the other inspected sheets. It also checked for named ranges and indirect references. Limitation: Technical Analysis contains approximately 3,950 rows and was checked by examining its formula patterns, not every individual cell. A hidden dependency there cannot be ruled out completely. Workbook status: No edits were made. Conclusion: Changing Financials!H65 affects the seven identified formula cells and the associated DPS chart. The count is subject to the stated Technical Analysis verification limitation.

Autosheet in Sheets Haiku 5.5 · High

Passed1m 31s · 10¢
Transcript excerptExpected answer
Changing Financials!H65 would recalculate 6 formula cells and update 1 chart. I made no edits. Financials!H65 is a hardcoded input (2.03 DPS for 2011), so it has no formula of its own to recalculate. Direct dependents (formulas that reference H65): - Financials!H66: payout ratio, =H65/H63 - Financials!U65: DPS growth for 2011, =IF(H65=0,"NA",IF(G65=0," ",H65/G65-1)) - Financials!V65: DPS growth for 2012, =IF(I65=0,"NA",IF(H65=0," ",I65/H65-1)) - Ratio_Analysis!H30: DPS 2011, =+Financials!H65 Downstream dependents: - Ratio_Analysis!H36: =+H30/H32 - Graphical_representation!P47: links to Ratio_Analysis!H30 - Graphical_representation!P48: links to Ratio_Analysis!H36 - The DPS chart on Graphical_representation (chart ID 1450268190), which plots P46:W48, updates its 2011 bars and line point. Checked and unaffected: Valuation, Assumptions, BB, and the rest of Financials have no references to H65. The other sheets were scanned through row 200, which covers their full content. Not fully checked: Technical Analysis has about 3,950 rows and was too large to scan. Its contents are price data, so I'd expect no link to Financials, but a Find search for "Financials!H65" there would confirm it.

ChatGPT in Excel GPT-6 Astra · Medium

Passed35s · 44¢
Transcript excerptExpected answer
I’ll trace H65’s direct and downstream dependents without editing. Changing Financials!H65 affects 7 formula cells: | Dependency | Affected cells | Path from H65 | |---|---|---| | Direct | (Financials!H66) | =H65/H63 | | Direct | (Financials!U65:V65) | Both growth formulas reference H65 | | Direct | (Ratio_Analysis!H30) | =+Financials!H65 | | Downstream | (Ratio_Analysis!H36) | Through Ratio_Analysis!H30 | | Downstream | (Graphical_representation!P47) | Through Ratio_Analysis!H30 | | Downstream | (Graphical_representation!P48) | Through Ratio_Analysis!H30 → H36 | No workbook changes were made.

Claude in Excel Haiku 5.5 · High

Passed43s · 1¢
Transcript excerptExpected answer
Changing Financials!H65 (a hardcoded 2.025) will recalculate 7 formula cells, and Chart 8 will update because it plots two of them. Direct dependents (4): - Financials!H66: =H65/H63 - Financials!U65 and Financials!V65: growth ratios that reference H65 - Ratio_Analysis!H30: =+Financials!H65 Downstream dependents (3): - Ratio_Analysis!H36: =H30/H32 - Graphical_representation!P47: =+'Ratio_Analysis '!H30 - Graphical_representation!P48: =+'Ratio_Analysis '!H36 Nothing downstream of H66, U65 or V65 depends on them further. Valuation, Assumptions, Technical Analysis and BB are not affected. I scanned formulas across all seven sheets, named ranges, and chart series. I found no INDIRECT or OFFSET formulas that could create hidden links. I did not check conditional formatting or data validation rules that reference H65. I made no edits to the workbook. I did not write anything to the workbook this turn. Every call was a read, so there is no change to undo. I re-read the cells to confirm the state: - Financials!H65 is still 2.025, a hardcoded input. - Financials!H66, U65, V65 still hold their original formulas and values (H66 = 0.502, U65 = 0.0714, V65 = 0.0506). - Ratio_Analysis!H30 and H36 still hold their original formulas and values (2.025 and 0.0219). - Graphical_representation!P47 and P48 still hold their original formulas and values (2.025 and 0.0219). The dependency trace from my previous answer stands. I did not check conditional formatting or data validation rules that might reference H65.

Claude in Sheets Haiku 5.5 · High

Passed1m 4s · 2¢
Transcript excerptExpected answer
Changing Financials!H65 (Reported DPS, 2011, currently the hardcoded 2.025) recalculates 7 formula cells. I made no edits. Direct dependents (depth 1) - Financials!H66: =H65/H63 (payout ratio) - Financials!U65 and Financials!V65: DPS growth formulas - Ratio_Analysis!H30: =+Financials!H65 Downstream dependents - Ratio_Analysis!H36: =H30/H32 (depth 2) - Graphical_representation!P47: =+'Ratio_Analysis '!H30 (depth 2) - Graphical_representation!P48: =+'Ratio_Analysis '!H36 (depth 3) Charts: The chart ranges P46:W48 include P47 and P48, so that chart's data will change on recalculation. The chart on D46:K48 has no direct link to H65's chain. Not affected: H66, U65 and V65 have no dependents of their own, so the chain stops there. Scope: I scanned all 73,103 formula cells across the workbook, with no INDIRECT or OFFSET references and no named ranges. I did not check conditional formatting or data validation.

Autosheet in Excel GPT-6 Luna · High

Passed21s · 2¢
Transcript excerptExpected answer
I’ll inspect formulas across the workbook and trace dependencies outward from Financials!H65, without changing any cells. I’ll report direct dependents separately from downstream dependents. Trace formula dependents from Financials!H65 Changing Financials!H65 directly affects formulas in Financials!U65, Financials!V65, Financials!H66, and 'Ratio_Analysis '!H30. Those changes flow downstream to 'Ratio_Analysis '!H36, Graphical_representation!P47, and Graphical_representation!P48. No workbook edits were made.

Copilot in Excel Auto

Passed1m 12s · N/A
Transcript excerptExpected answer
Changing Financials!H65 triggers 7 formula cells. No workbook edits were made. Direct dependents - Financials!U65 - Financials!V65 - Financials!H66 - 'Ratio_Analysis '!H30 Downstream dependents - 'Ratio_Analysis '!H36 - Graphical_representation!P47 - Graphical_representation!P48 excel U65 = H65/G65-1 V65 = I65/H65-1 H66 = H65/H63 H30 = Financials!H65 H36 = H30/H32 P47 = 'Ratio_Analysis '!H30 P48 = 'Ratio_Analysis '!H36 Current outputs include 7.1% in Financials!U65, 5.1% in Financials!V65, and 50.2% in Financials!H66. No additional downstream formula cells were found.

ChatGPT + Drive MCP GPT-6 · Medium

Passed1m 9s · N/A
Transcript excerptExpected answer
Changing Financials!H65 will cause 7 formula cells to recalculate across 3 worksheets, based on the dependency trace of the Google spreadsheet. Affected formula cells 7 Direct dependents 4 Downstream dependents 3 1. Direct dependents These formulas reference Financials!H65 directly. Worksheet Cell Formula Financials U65 =IF(H65=0,"NA",IF(G65=0," ",H65/G65-1)) Financials V65 =IF(I65=0,"NA",IF(H65=0," ",I65/H65-1)) Financials H66 =H65/H63 Ratio_Analysis H30 =+Financials!H65 2. Downstream dependents These formulas depend on cells that are themselves affected. Worksheet Cell Formula Ratio_Analysis H36 =+H30/H32 Graphical_representation P47 =+'Ratio_Analysis '!H30 Graphical_representation P48 =+'Ratio_Analysis '!H36 3. Dependency flow Financials!H65 Original input cell Financials U65, V65, H66 Direct, no further dependents Ratio_Analysis H30 Direct H36 Downstream Graphical_representation P47 depends on H30 P48 depends on H36 4. Complete affected-cell list Copyable cell references Copy Financials!U65 Financials!V65 Financials!H66 'Ratio_Analysis '!H30 'Ratio_Analysis '!H36 Graphical_representation!P47 Graphical_representation!P48 Conclusion: The formula dependency trace identifies 7 affected cells, excluding the original input Financials!H65. Recalculation does not necessarily mean the displayed value of every affected cell will change. The trace covered formulas across all 7 tabs. The workbook was not edited. Note: The Ratio_Analysis tab name contains a trailing space, which is preserved in the full cell references.

ChatGPT in Excel GPT-6 Luna · High

Passed2m 47s · 2¢
Transcript excerptExpected answer
I’ll trace formulas from H65 through every downstream dependent, without editing anything. I’ve isolated four true direct links; now tracing their downstream formulas. Changing Financials!H65 recalculates these formula cells: - Direct dependents: Financials!H66, Financials!U65, Financials!V65, and Ratio_Analysis!H30. (Financials!H65, Financials!H66, Financials!U65:V65, Ratio_Analysis!H30) - Downstream dependents: Ratio_Analysis!H36, Graphical_representation!P47, and Graphical_representation!P48. (Ratio_Analysis!H36, Graphical_representation!P47:P48) No further formula-cell dependents were found. I did not edit the workbook.

ChatGPT in Sheets GPT-6 Astra · Medium

Passed2m 30s · 79¢
Transcript excerptExpected answer
I’ll trace direct and downstream dependents without changing any cells. A réfléchi quelques secondes I found four direct dependents; I’m checking downstream endpoints. Thought for 2m 26s Changing Financials!H65 affects 7 formula cells: 4 direct and 3 downstream. Dependency Affected cell Formula Direct FinancialsH66 =H65/H63 Direct FinancialsU65 =IF(H65=0,"NA",IF(G65=0," ",H65/G65-1)) Direct FinancialsV65 =IF(I65=0,"NA",IF(H65=0," ",I65/H65-1)) Direct Ratio_AnalysisH30 =+Financials!H65 Downstream via H30 Ratio_AnalysisH36 =+H30/H32 Downstream via H30 Graphical_representationP47 =+'Ratio_Analysis '!H30 Downstream via H36 Graphical_representationP48 =+'Ratio_Analysis '!H36 No further formula dependents were found. Recalculation does not necessarily mean every result changes—for example, the IF formulas can return text depending on the inputs. The workbook was not edited.

ChatGPT in Sheets GPT-6 Luna · High

Passed4m 19s · 1¢
Transcript excerptExpected answer
I’ll trace formulas from H65 through each dependent layer, without editing. Thought for a few seconds Direct links are confirmed; I’m checking one more formula layer across sheets. Thought for a few seconds The dependency chain looks localized; I’m verifying the terminal display links. Thought for 4m 15s Changing Financials!H65 would recalculate these formula cells: ‌ Direct dependents: Financials!U65, Financials!V65, and Financials!H66 FinancialsU65:V65 FinancialsH66; plus Ratio_Analysis!H30, which links to Financials!H65. Ratio_AnalysisH30 ‌ Downstream dependents: Ratio_Analysis!H36 depends on H30 Ratio_AnalysisH36; Graphical_representation!P47 links to H30, and P48 links to H36. Graphical_representationP47:P48 That’s 7 dependent cells total. I found no further formula dependents beyond these; no workbook edits were made.

Failed 1

Gemini in Sheets Auto

Failed1m 13s · N/A
Transcript excerptExpected answer
If you change Financials!H65 (Reported DPS for FY 2011, currently 2.025), the following 3 cells will recalculate: 1. Direct Formula Dependents Financials!H66 (Payout Ratio for FY 2011) Formula: =H65 / H63 (Reported DPS / Reported EPS - Diluted) Current Value: 50.2% Explanation: Calculates the proportion of diluted earnings per share paid out as dividends in 2011. Updating H65 changes the numerator. Financials!U65 (Growth YoY (%) for Reported DPS in 2011) Formula: =(H65 - G65) / G65 Current Value: 7.1% Explanation: Calculates Year-over-Year growth in DPS from 2010 (G65 = 1.89) to 2011 (H65 = 2.025). Updating H65 directly changes the 2011 value in this rate of change formula. Financials!V65 (Growth YoY (%) for Reported DPS in 2012) Formula: =(I65 - H65) / H65 Current Value: 5.1% Explanation: Calculates Year-over-Year growth in DPS from 2011 (H65 = 2.025) to 2012 (I65 = 2.1275). Updating H65 directly changes the base/denominator for 2012's growth calculation. 2. Downstream Formula Dependents None: Financials!Q65 (FY 08–13 DPS CAGR) depends only on the start period 2008 (E65) and end period 2013 (J65). Forecast DPS (Financials!K65:O65) is driven by 2013 actuals (J65) and forecast growth rates rather than 2011 historical actuals. Historical Cash Flow Statement items (such as 2011 Dividends Paid in H118) are hardcoded reported historical figures rather than formulas linked to H65.

Why it failed: The assistant failed to identify direct dependent Ratio_Analysis!H30 and downstream dependents Ratio_Analysis!H36, Graphical_representation!P47, and Graphical_representation!P48.